Best Diaper Pail For Maximum Odor Control with Budget Friendly

Diaper changes are a necessary part of parenting. However, it is hard to ignore the beastly smells that remain when your baby releases into her/his diaper. There is hope. That smell does not have to contaminate the rest of your home. With the right diaper pail you could trap the odors and keep stinky dirty diapers contained.

A diaper pail is similar to a trash can. It is a receptacle. It has been created with certain features that help dispel baby diaper smell. It is specially made to prevent the odor from spreading from the container to the air around your home.


There are a number of choices on the market, making it difficult to chose from among them. There is no one size fits all product. This is why it is important to understand what kinds of diaper pails exist and the distinguishing characteristics of each.

This guide will cover the best diaper pail review to help you navigate the marketplace and choose the best one for a pleasant nursery. These are the best diaper pail reviews 2017.

Top 5 Diaper Pails Comparison Table

Product Name

Dimensions & Weight 


Foot pedal

Editors Rating

Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail

15x10.8x22.5 inches
7.0 pounds



Playtex Diaper Genie Elite Pail System

6.8 pounds



Munchkin Arm & Hammer Diaper Pail

11x11.4x21.1 inches
3.9 pounds



Munchkin Step Diaper Pail


12.2x27.6x13 inches
12.1 pounds



Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail

22.3x12.5x9 inches
6.7 pounds



**Below, you'll find our more detailed reviews, but you can also click the links above to see current prices or read customer reviews on Amazon.

Best Diaper Pail for Maximum Odor Control 1

Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail - Best Diaper Pail for Maximum Odor Control
(src Amazon)

Parents change diapers each and every day. They accumulate a high number of dirty diapers in the process. They need a disposal system that offers ease of use and a way to get rid of soiled diapers. The Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail offers a modern take on this age old problem.

This product is a nursery must have. The small is securely locked away inside the container. The product comes in a range of colors and prints so parents are not stuck with only one monochrome color option. This allows modern parents to coordinate with their nursery décor.

Its powder coated steel construction is built to last. It also includes rubber seals to trap odors. This pail does not require specialized bags making it an affordable option. Many will appreciate being able to use a standard kitchen garbage bag or a reusable cloth bag of choice. The bag holder has been updated to avoid breakage of the bag inside.

The Features We Like

  • It is the ONLY diaper pail made out of stainless steel, which is sturdy and doesn’t absorb smells over time like some cheap plastic pails
  • The colors look super fun and chic. There are 10 colors for you to find one that fits in well with the rest of your decor.
  • Ability to keep the smells contained is very impressive.
  • It has a child-proof lock. That’s precious because we all know how messy a curious baby can make

The Things We Didn't Like

  • Price is the biggest “barrier” which makes you are not willing to buy one Ubbi pail. It’s more expensive than the other options
  • There is no foot pedal, you have to use hands and this is quite inconvenient.
  • Cloth diaper bag is not that waterproof.
  • Not equipped with a twist-and-shut feature.
Best Hygienic Diaper Disposal reviews 2

Playtex Diaper Genie Elite Pail System - Best Hygienic Diaper Disposal (src Amazon)

A clean baby is a happy baby. This is why maintaining a clean and sanitary nursery is imperative. No one wants to experience a pungent nursery. The Playtex Diaper Genie Elite Disposal system keeps your home smelling fresh. It provides an effective method to get rid of dirty diapers in your child’s room. This helps you keep your sanity and establish a clean and healthy home for your baby.

This diaper pail is a great buy for parents of younger infants. It allows your to attend to your baby and dispose of diapers at the same time; without having to stoop. It includes a carbon filter. This traps the noxious odors and keeps them at bay.

The system has a large capacity as it can hold roughly 270 diapers. This can cut down on the time spent emptying it as its large capacity requires less frequent changing. It comes with 5 layer protection. It offers ease of disposal and simplifies things in the nursery.

The diaper pail is packaged with the pail, carbon filter, filter case and 100 diaper bail refills.Some may feel grade down the Playtex Diaper Genie Elite Pail System as it requires carbon filters. These are an additional expense that some buyers can’t think to justify.

The Features We Like

  • It has foot pedal - a small yet super convenient for users
  • Odor lock protection
  • Lightweight and very easy to assembled
  • No more smelliness! The odor from dirty diapers were kept inside very well
  • Ability to keep the smells contained is very impressive

The Things We Didn't Like

  • A little bit expensive
  • You have to buy special bags for it
Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail – Best Diaper Pail with Refill Bags 3

Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail – Best Diaper Pail with Refill Bags (src amazon)

The Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail is among the best diaper pail reviews as it is a popular model with good reason. It utilizes baking soda to get rid of bad odors.

The pail’s self sealing feature is a highly desired one. It locks away the odors of dirty diapers. When the lid closes, this releases a layer of baking soda over the dirty diapers. This traps odors away and is an effective technology. The bags are sealed away due to the self-sealing feature of the pail so others are not subjected to the odor when opening the pail.

The diaper pail refill bags hold 25 diapers. These are super easy to dispose of and don’t require parents to tie off or cut the bags.

The pail comes with the pail and one refill bag.

The Features We Like

  • Equipped with proven odor-eliminating baking soda
  • Self-sealing system. Bag seals the bag as lid closes
  • One hand use
  • You can open the door in the front and see how full the bag is

The Things We Didn't Like

  • You need to physically push the diaper down into the pail
  • The lid doesn't close automatically
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail – The Best Diaper Pail

Munchkin Step Diaper Pail – The Best Diaper Pail (src amazon)

The Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is a diaper pail that is aesthetically pleasing, making it perfect for any nursery. Its design cuts down on the dirty diaper vapors. Offensive diaper smells are locked away from the start.

The step pedal design leaves one hand free for baby while you toss the dirty diaper into the pail. This will appeal to new parents that don’t want to be away from their baby for even a moment.

One minus is the refills. They can be an added expense that some of a strict budget may not want to spring for.

The Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is designed utilize both refill rings, snap seal & toss refill bags. This makes it a great option as it provides more choices for users.

The Features We Like

  • Easy to use foot pedal
  • Innovative self-sealing technology
  • Stops odor with Arm and Hammer lavender baking soda puck
  • Safety first with child-proof lock

The Things We Didn't Like

  • Costly refills
Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail – Best Diaper Pail for Cloth Diapers

Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail – Best Diaper Pail for Cloth Diapers (src Amazon)

Diaper changes are a daily necessity that the Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail simplifies for you.

The pail holds up to 45 diapers. This means a longer span between bag changes. This pail keeps your hands free and away from yucky diapers. There is no need to handles the disgusting stinky diapers to make room for the next one. The pail is really hands free. Simply step on the foot pedal and toss in the dirty diaper. This is hygienic as it keeps hands clean and away from the mess.

The pail comes in a range of colors allowing it to coordinate with a range of decors. Manufacturers included a number of features to keep odors at bay. First, it is composed of ABS plastic that doesn’t absorb odors. It also lasts and is scratch resistant. Second, it resists odors and leaves a baby powder scent.

As it does such a good job trapping odors, spring for a couple to use in the nursery, kitchen or anywhere else around the house. It also can be used as a pet waste receptacle. So, no more stinky kitty litter with this pail.

The Features We Like

  • Hands-free action
  • Superb odor control
  • Childproof lock
  • Equipped with continuous liners
  • Trap door uses rubber gaskets to lock in odors
  • Made with a fade and odor resistant ABS plastic

The Things We Didn't Like

  • Trap door tends to stick sometimes

Diaper pails are easy to use! (via

Best Diaper Pail – Buyer’s Guide

As a parent or caregiver, you have to change diapers often. Babies are cute and adorable. However, the surprises they leave in their diapers are often not as fun or pleasant. For those on the go, dirty diaper disposal can pose a real dilemma. You want to toss the offensive diapers into a pail. However, you don’t want to waste time fighting with the bag to try to seal it off so it doesn’t mess up the rest of the house.

The latest pails on the market address this issue. This is why they are a great buy for a new parent or an expectant one. It cuts down on trips to the outside garbage bin to toss old diapers.

To choose the best diaper pail you need to look at all of the features and designs. This guide will making choosing a pail for your nursery a bit easier.

Classification of Diaper Pails

Diaper pails fall into 3 major classifications; wet, dry or both. A dry diaper pail is perfect for cloth and disposable diapers. These have to be use with a liner & may require more frequent emptying. A wet diaper mail is with water to soak cloth diapers before laundering. This can be a positive and help parents avoid stains as the diapers are soaked in water before washing. Add a bit of baking soda to the water to boost its stain fighting power.

Combination pails contain dry and wet diapers. However, you would rinse off the solid or liquid waste before tossing the diaper into the pail.

Material Choice

Diaper pails can be composed of plastic and metal. Both have advantages.

Metal pails can contain odors better and have a more modern look. They can be more long lasting than the plastic pails.

Plastic pails are less expensive and more readily available. They don’t absorb odors as well as metal pails and don’t last as long. Plastic can crack as it ages.

Features to Look For

Odor Control

The best diaper pails have some type of odor control technology. The whole reason for buying a diaper pail is to keep a lid on odors. Air filters, scented pail liners and added fragrances are all things to check off on your list of desired features.


Best Diaper Pail For Maximum Odor Control with Budget Friendly (via

Diaper Pail Liners

Diaper pail liners are plastic bags that are placed within the diaper pail itself to hold the dirty diapers. Some pails can hold ordinary bags purchased from an area merchant. Other use a proprietary pail liner. These can be expensive. Anti-bacterial coating is a positive to look for as the coating helps stop bacteria and germs from growing within and on the bag.

Those who are counting every coin may consider buying a diaper pail that doesn’t require the use of proprietary liners. They may opt instead for a liner capable of using traditional trash bags. This can save money for them.

Cloth diapering parents should choose a pail designed for cloth diapers. These use a cloth bag. The upside for these pails is that the dirty diapers and their bag can be washes together as one unit. This cuts down on the mess as there is not bag to throw away once filled. It is eco-friendly as you are using a reusable cloth diaper. It can also be a great idea for those with sensitivity or allergies to commercial diapers.


Consider capacity when purchasing your pail. The smaller the pail and capacity, the more often you will have to empty it. For parents of multiples and those wanting to empty the pail less often, choose a pail with a larger capacity. These will hold more diapers and require emptying much less often. This can save you trips to the curbside trash bin.

However, odors can attempt to build up as higher capacity pails hold more diapers. To counter this, consider adding a bit of baking soda or vinegar to the liner bag to combat bad odors. You can also use a scented liner as well.

Foot Pedals

Choosing a pail with a foot pedal is a great option for those with very young babies, first time parents and busy caregivers. A foot pedal allows for hands free operation. One hand can quickly toss in a dirty diaper. However, you wouldn’t have to stoop or bend over to open the pail lid as it is operated via the foot pedal. These types of pails are a real time saver.

Once you have reviewed the best diaper pail reviews as well as the most convenient features, I hope this list makes it a bit easier to choose a great diaper pail.


I’m Elizabeth J. Johnson, a 30-year-old from sunny California. I have married to a wonderful man & have 2 little girls. They are the cutest lover, the sweetest hugger & the best inspiration.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments